Putting the brakes on costs

- High precision, non-ventilated brake discs with cross-grind finish are complete-machined, ready for despatch, on a fully automated production line consisting of three VSC multi-functional production centers that implement a cleverly thought out tooling strategy.
The life of every driver depends on how safe his brakes are.
Brake discs have become a global mass product, but one that makes enormous demands on safety. In the end, the life of every driver depends, often more than just once every day, on the safety of his brakes. At present, 600 million passenger cars travel the roads and byways of the world. Let us assume that during the 10 to 14 years of the life of a car the brake discs are being replaced at least once – and that a quarter of all passenger cars are still equipped with drum brakes – and we arrive at an annual global requirement of approximately 400 million discs.
At present, over 500 VSC Multi-Functional Production Centers from Emag in Salach are employed worldwide in the machining of brake discs – in space-saving sets of between four and eight, fully automatically interlinked to form complete brake disc production lines. These lines produce on average of between 400,000 and 800,000 discs a year – in a number of variants – from cast iron raw-part to finely balanced end product, ready for despatch. Brake disc production lines do not come “off the peg”. In every case there are individual, customer-specific requirements to be met. Where large batches are produced the demand for resetting is low. Such lines are totally different to those required for a spare parts production environment with small batch sizes and frequent resetting. A line for ventilated brake discs has a different specification to one for unventilated discs. High-powered limousines that travel at over 160 mph on, for instance, German roads need different brakes to those for cars driven in countries where the speed limit is 60 or 70 mph. In 2001/2002 a brake disc production line was designed, manufactured, tested, accepted and delivered in record time to a well known manufacturer of brake components in a far away continent. Such production lines are usually planned and implemented in partnership with experienced tool manufacturers. Only a successful combination of machine technology and tooling strategy produces a satisfactory solution for the customer. The technology partner in this case, as in many previous cases, was Kennametal, a tool manufacturer known across the globe for his extensive knowledge and experience in the field of vehicular technology.
Three machines instead of four

- Two VSC 400s and one VSC 500, interlinked by Heilig automation, constitute the total of the brake disc production line. (Editor’s note: Owing to the particularly sensitive nature of this high-productivity solution it is impossible to name the customer or to show the installation in detail. The installation pictured is of a similar design and consists of 5 VSC machines.)
Before, it had been customary to use at least four interlinked VSC machines for the complete-machining of brake discs. A new aspect of this particular solution was the attempt to achieve the same result with a line of just three machines. The problem faced was an obvious one: required capacity. The task was to produce 200,000 brake discs for passenger cars per annum – of the same type, not internally ventilated (owing to the speed limit in the country), in a material comparable to grey cast iron, with a disc diameter of 300 mm. The finish-machining operation was to be cross-grinding, to achieve a better surface finish. Other requirements were dry machining, balancing, a test certificate, and the components finish-machined, ready for despatch. The required cycle time: less than 100 seconds, all inclusive. This type of disc makes greater demands on the manufacturing technology, as it is less stable during machining than the ventilated variety. Brake discs are also increasing in size, but are not supposed to get heavier. Larger diameters achieve a higher braking torque. The braking area is moving further away from the centre. As a result of these changes the discs are getting thinner and sometimes tend to flutter. This is as much a problem during machining as it is later during braking. Those drivers clamouring for greater comfort and a quieter car do not take kindly to braking noises and fluttering. Ergo, the brake discs must be manufactured to the highest precision.
Hundredfold experience worldwide
Emag and Kennametal commend themselves for their hundredfold experience in this particular technology and for their successful worldwide installations. The basic construction of the VSC from Emag already makes the machine exceptionally vibration resistant. This is helped by its base in Mineralit and a hydrostatic guideway; whilst its thermo-symmetrical design lends it thermo-stability. Rigid, stationary tooling systems, embedded in the machine base, make for a high degree of precision and a long tool life. This leads to calculable and eminently capable processes. The prerequisites of stability provided by the machine are supported by the tooling systems from Kennametal.
A cleverly thought out tooling strategy

- The tooling / machine tool project team (from left): Bernhard Ihring, team leader at Emag, Dipl.-Ing. Frank Schiffler, Sales Director Advanced Sales Europe at Kennametal and Dr.-Ing. Ulrich Walter, Manager Department Tools and Technologies. Fastest possible project finalisation, aided by the many shared experiences. A second order from this customer already in hand.
The two VSC 400s and one VSC 500 are linked up by automation equipment from Heilig (also part of the EMAG Group). This forms a continuous, fully automated line from collection of the workpieces stored in skeleton containers via turnover stations to the component’s final destination – packing. The fist station (a VSC 400) turns, drills, taps and gauges the first side of the component. The rough machining operation uses KM special heads that accommodate single and twin tool tips coated with silicon nitride (Kyon 3400). The coating increases tool life by about 30%. Combination drilling and chamfering tools plus threading tools complete the tooling equipment for the first station. The second station (also a VSC 400) turns, drills and gauges the second side of the component. Equipment: the same as station 1, plus solid carbide step drills and solid carbide fraises, the latter chucked in live tool holders using expansion chuck technology from Kenna. The third station (a VSC 500) turns, grinds, balances and gauges and also generates a protocol. The result of including all these operations in a complete-machining cycle that requires only a single set-up is a considerable leap in component quality. The deviation in the thickness of the discs is below 3 µm, the surface finish below Rz 6.3 µm, with parallelism/runout also being in the µ-range. The tooling used for the finishing-operations consists of an NC twin cutter head KM50 for the simultaneous machining of both brake surfaces, a further NC twin cutter head KM50 for the machining of the contact surface of the cup, and two CBN grinding wheels for the cross-grinding of the brake surfaces. The final tool in the third station is a solid carbide balance fraise.
The future taken care of
The whole installation is designed for the machining with ceramic tools, but already prepared for the future use of CBN tools, which would – if necessary – reduce the cycle time even more and increase the output by 25 percent (ceramics allow cutting speeds of up to 700 m/min, whereas CBN can accommodate speeds of 900 m/min and higher). The experience gathered with many similar applications and projects, and the high international profile, are shared by both partners, the machine tool builder Emag and the tool manufacturer Kennametal. It was that shared experience in particular that made sure the two companies’ first combination of machines and tooling already provided near optimal results. Nevertheless, a further potential for optimisation became apparent during commissioning and was quickly acted upon. The total planning time ran to 6 months. Pre-acceptance trials showed a process capability of Cpk 1.67, i.e. 95 percent of the parameters resided in the tolerance zone of 2/3. The two partners, Emag and Kennametal, have since been asked to supply a second brake disc manufacturing line.
Report taken from Maschine+Werkzeug 10.2003
FURTHER INFORMATION
The VSC 400
More about the VSC 400
The EMAG Product Summary
Download
brochures / quotation
request
Recall
request
